Guidelines & Rules for Great Debate
Debate Format:
Each debate will last 20 minutes and include the following:
- Team 1: Affirmative argument (6 min)
- Team 2: Counter argument (4 min)
- Team 1: Rebuttal (3 min)
- Team 2: Rebuttal (3 min)
- Team 1: Final words (3 min)
Requirements:
- Annotated bibliography using MLA format with 6-8 sources. Sources should include a variety of the following: opinion articles, journal articles, newspaper articles, books, documentaries, and/or news media. (20 points)
- 1-2 page typed summary of argument: team’s claim, assertions, support/evidence, possible counter arguments and rebuttals - this should serve as your guide for the debate. (25 points)
- Inclusion of “They Say, I Say” strategies in your summary & during the debate (15 points)
- Rebuttals with cited evidence during debate (20 points)
Optional:
- Visual presentation support - digital (or not) presentation to support your argument. Might include images or video clips - this should enhance and not take away from your claim. Keep in mind that a long video clip may not leave you with enough time to explain your position and ultimately weaken your argument.
Oral Presentation (20 points) Guidelines:
- Respect all members of the debate
- Refrain from talking to your partner while debate is in process – pass notes only
- Do not make personal attacks or comments
- Take copious notes during debate and number your points of argumentation and rebuttal
- Address the speakers professionally
- Speak clearly and confidently
- All team members participate
- Make eye contact!
